Which shingle style suits your home?
If you are planning a roof replacement in Lanark, start by comparing three-tab, architectural and designer asphalt shingles. These styles offer different profiles and appearances. The right choice also depends on your roof's suitability, the specific product and the work included in your estimate.
This guide explains the main shingle types and gives you questions to bring to a roofing discussion. For installation enquiries, explore our asphalt shingle roofing services or ask McKay Roofing for an estimate.
Three types of asphalt roofing shingles
Asphalt shingles come in different profiles. Manufacturers may use terms such as strip, laminated, dimensional or luxury, so check the exact product rather than comparing names alone.
| Shingle style | Appearance | What to compare |
|---|---|---|
| Three-tab | A flat, repeating pattern with three tabs. | Product availability, installed price and warranty terms. |
| Architectural | Bonded layers create a more dimensional profile. | Colour samples, product ratings and the complete roof system. |
| Designer / luxury | A more pronounced profile, often styled to resemble slate or wood. | The specific look, product weight and additional cost. |
Three-tab asphalt shingles
Three-tab shingles, also called strip shingles, have a uniform look and generally cost less as a material than more elaborate asphalt designs. That does not establish the lowest price for your entire roof: removal, roof condition and installation details still matter. Ask which products are available for your project.
Architectural or dimensional shingles
Architectural shingles are also called laminated or dimensional shingles. Their layered construction adds depth instead of the even pattern of three-tab shingles. Compare actual samples and the specifications for each proposed product; the category name alone does not tell you its wind or impact rating.
Designer or luxury shingles
Designer shingles put more emphasis on shape, texture and a distinctive roofline. Some imitate the appearance of wood shakes or slate while remaining asphalt products. They are worth comparing when appearance is a priority, but a premium label is not a substitute for checking the product documentation.
Metal, cedar, slate and clay: different material choices
Looking beyond asphalt changes the comparison. These are alternatives to discuss, not a list of products McKay installs on every project.
- Metal shingles: compare the shingle profile with other metal roof systems. See our steel shingles guide for a closer look.
- Cedar shingles or shakes: discuss the desired wood appearance, maintenance and suitability with your contractor.
- Slate and clay tile: these are distinct materials, not asphalt shingle grades. Confirm structural suitability, installation requirements and availability before making a selection.
If your main decision is asphalt versus metal, our asphalt shingles vs. metal roofing comparison for Lanark homes takes a closer look at those two options.
How to choose shingles for your Lanark home
Shortlist the appearance you prefer, then ask your contractor to assess what suits your roof. For a Lanark property, discuss how the proposed roof system addresses snow, ice and drainage, along with any existing leaks or ventilation concerns. Use these questions to compare estimates on the same basis.
- Is this roof suitable for the product? Ask about slope, the condition of the roof deck and any sections that need a different roofing system. Asphalt shingles are used on sloped roofs; a low-slope section needs its own assessment.
- What is included beneath and around the shingles? Review underlayment, leak protection, starter shingles and flashing details. Shingles are only one part of the roof. Attic ventilation also deserves attention.
- How does the colour look outdoors? Compare physical samples alongside your siding, brick and trim. Screen images and small swatches can look different from a finished roof.
- What does each estimate actually include? Ask for the exact shingle model, removal and disposal, any decking allowance, accessories and installation scope. Compare those details alongside the total.
- Which warranty applies? Request the manufacturer's written product terms and the contractor's workmanship terms. Review exclusions and conditions rather than treating a warranty label as a promised roof lifespan.
Common questions about roofing shingles
Are fibreglass shingles different from asphalt shingles?
They can describe the same shingle: fibreglass is the reinforcing mat, while asphalt is another component. Our asphalt and fibreglass shingle roofing guide explains the construction in more detail. When choosing a product, compare its style and written specifications.
Which roofing shingles are best for a Lanark home?
There is no single best product for every home. Start with a roof assessment, then compare suitable options against your preferred appearance, project budget and written product requirements. A shortlist is more useful than choosing by a brand name alone.
How long will a shingle roof last?
A product warranty is not a prediction of the date a roof will need replacing. The roof system, installation, exposure and maintenance all matter. If you are deciding whether to replace an existing roof, read what to expect from a roof inspection.
Compare shingle options for your home
Ready to narrow down your options? Tell McKay Roofing where your Lanark property is, whether you are planning a replacement or investigating a roof problem, and which shingle styles you prefer. Ask for an estimate that identifies the proposed product and installation scope.
Request a roofing estimate Call (613) 259-5766Further reading
For general product terminology, see CertainTeed's asphalt shingle categories, IKO's architectural shingle guide and GAF's roof-system overview. These explain materials; they do not confirm McKay's current product availability.